Joshua Lewis persists in pulling Halloween practical jokes on Molly Little, his stepsister. Joshua waits for Molly to find the mice he's concealed in the carton while she walks to the refrigerator to grab some eggs. Molly screams when she discovers the rubber mice and tells her stepbrother that he doesn't even know who she is and that she gets incredibly aroused whenever she feels afraid. Joshua is warned by her not to frighten her again or he will have to conceive her. Later, Joshua tricks Molly once more by pretending to be a frightening guy and peeking through her window. When Molly notices it, she screams until Joshua arrives to inquire about the situation. Molly threatens to scream until he fucks her, but Joshua rips his dick off and puts a cock in her mouth to silence her. Molly was dying for a blowjob to begin with, but that's not all she wants. She eventually gets her wish when Joshua dunks his balls into that creamy coochie. She sits on top of Joshua to ride him in cowgirl mode, continuing her pussy party. She turns around and keeps her ride going while bouncing her booty up and down. Joshua can easily slip behind Molly and ride her in the doggy since she's already on her hands and knees. Joshua's stepsis wants him to give her a creampie when he tells her he's going to cum. After Joshua gives birth, he finds out that Molly isn't using birth control.